Is SGC as good as PSA? Why People Choose SGC to Authenticate and Grade Trading Cards

Is SGC as good as PSA? Why People Choose SGC to Authenticate and Grade Trading Cards

When it comes to the trading card market, authentication and grading play a pivotal role in determining the value and desirability of a card. Two dominant forces in this field are SGC (Sportscard Guaranty Corporation) and PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator). While both have been key players in the industry for many years, there is an ongoing debate as to which of the two is superior. Here’s why SGC has advantages over PSA – particularly in terms of authentication and valuation.

Experience and Expertise

SGC has a long-standing history in the industry, having been established in 1998. With over two decades of experience, SGC has proven itself in grading a wide array of sports and non-sports trading cards. Their experts have developed an in-depth understanding of the various nuances that influence a card’s value, ensuring a thorough, accurate, and transparent grading process.

Grading Scale

SGC utilizes a 10-point grading scale, with increments of 0.5, for the grading of modern cards. This offers a more precise and detailed breakdown compared to PSA’s larger scale. Furthermore, SGC’s scale provides clarity about the exact condition of a card, giving collectors and buyers a better understanding of a card’s real value.


SGC has earned a reputation for its consistent grading. The consistent methodology means that the same card submitted at different times is likely to receive the same grade. This reliability is critical for collectors and dealers who need to trust that the grading will be consistent and objective.

Turnaround Time

PSA has notoriously been known for its long turnaround times, especially during periods of high demand. SGC, on the other hand, typically offers faster turnaround times for their grading services, which can be a major advantage for collectors and dealers eager to have their cards graded and ready for sale.

Customer Service

SGC card Grading places a strong emphasis on customer service, with a dedicated staff who is responsive and informative. They provide consistent updates about the status of submissions, ensuring customers are always informed. This level of concierge service sets them apart and provides a superior experience for users.

Authenticity Verification

SGC uses advanced technology for authentication, reducing the risk of counterfeit cards entering the market. Their expert graders are adept at identifying any tampering or restoration attempts on a card, ensuring collectors can trust the authenticity of their graded cards.

Market Recognition

While PSA might have a larger market share, SGC-graded cards have been gaining traction in the market. Collectors and investors have started recognizing the value and reliability of SGC grades, which has resulted in a growing demand and solid resale value.

While both SGC and PSA have their strengths and weaknesses, SGC stands out in terms of consistent, precise grading, faster turnaround times, exceptional customer service, and superior authentication methods. When it comes to trading card authentication and valuation, SGC presents a strong case for being the preferred choice for collectors and dealers alike. While the decision ultimately depends on individual preference, it’s undeniable that SGC brings a unique and valuable set of benefits to the table.

Click here to start your SGC bulk submission today!

Skip to content